PDA

View Full Version : Iraqi snipers fuel frustration of GIs


Felix the Cat
11-07-2006, 03:36 PM
http://www.iht.com/articles/2006/11/03/news/sniper.php?page=1

The bullet passed through Lance Corporal Juan Valdez- Castillo as his patrol moved down a muddy urban lane. It was a single shot. The marine fell against a wall, tried to stand and fell again. His squad leader, Sergeant Jesse Leach, faced where the shot had come from, raised his rifle and grenade launcher and quickly stepped between the sniper and the bloodied marine. He walked backward, scanning, ready to fire.

Shielding the marine with his own thick body, he grabbed the lance corporal by a strap and dragged him to a line of tall reeds, where they were concealed. He put down his weapon, shouted orders and cut open the lance corporal's uniform, exposing a bubbling wound.

Valdez-Castillo, shot through the right arm and torso, was saved. But the patrol was temporarily stuck. The marines were engaged in the task of calling for a casualty evacuation while staring down their barrels at dozens of windows that faced them, as if waiting for a ghost's next move.

This sequence on Tuesday here in the Anbar Province captured, in a matter of seconds, an expanding threat in the war in Iraq. In recent months, military officers and enlisted marines say, the insurgents have been using snipers more frequently and with greater effect, disrupting the military's operations and fueling a climate of frustration and quiet rage.

Throughout Iraq, the threat has become serious enough that in late October the military held an internal conference about it, sharing the experiences of combat troops and discussing tactics to counter it. There has been no ready fix.

In Leach's unit, 2nd Battalion, 8th Marines, the battalion commander recounted in an interview eight sniper hits on his marines in three months, and said there were other possible incidents as well. Two of the battalion's five fatalities have come from snipers, he said, and one marine who was shot by a sniper is in a coma. Another gravely wounded marine has suffered a stroke.

An enemy sniper team was captured in the area a few weeks ago, he said, but more have taken its place. "The enemy has the ability to regenerate, and after we put a dent in his activity, we see sniper activity again," said the commander, Lieutenant Colonel Kenneth DeTreux.

Marines in two infantry companies recounted even more incidents, telling of lone shots that have zipped in as if from nowhere, striking turrets and walls within inches of marines. They typically occur when the marines are not engaged in combat with the enemy. It is as if, they say, they are being watched.

By many measures, the Iraqi snipers have showed unexceptional marksmanship skills, usually shooting from inside 300 meters, far less than ranges preferred by the elite snipers in Western military units. But as the insurgents' sniper teams have become more active, the marines here say, they have displayed greater skill, selecting both their targets and their firing positions with care. They have also developed cunning methods of mobility and concealment, including firing from shooting platforms and hidden ports within cars.

They often use variants of the long- barreled Dragunov rifle, which shoots higher-powered ammunition than the much more common Kalashnikov assault rifles.

"In the beginning of the war, sniping wasn't something that the Iraqis did," said Captain Glen Taylor, executive officer of the battalion's Golf Company, who is on his third combat tour. "It was like, 'If Allah wants that bullet to hit its target, it will.' But they are starting to realize how effective it is."

The insurgents are also recruiting snipers and centralizing their instruction, the captain said, meaning the phenomenon is likely to grow. "They have training camps, they go around and advertise," he said. "We heard from some of our sources that the insurgents were going around with loudspeakers, saying that if you want to be a sniper, we will pay you three times whatever your salary is now."

Most of the time, the marines said, the snipers aim for the troops' heads, necks and armpits, displaying knowledge of gaps in their protective gear. They typically shoot once and disappear. And they often fire from among civilians or on the opposite side of obstacles like canals, which limits a unit's ability to capture the sniper or respond with fire. "That's the biggest things that tears marines apart," said Corporal Curtis Cota-Robles, of Golf Company, who was standing beside a marine who was shot through the collarbone in late September. "They hit us when we are vulnerable and then they are gone."

As part of their counterinsurgency operations, the marines working in Anbar are under orders to show restraint, a policy rooted in hopes of winning the trust of the civilian population.

Iraqi snipers seem to know these rules, and use them for their own protection. They often fire from among civilians, the marines say, having observed that unless the marines have a clear target, they will not shoot. (In two sniping incidents witnessed by two journalists for The New York Times on Oct. 30 and 31, the snipers fired from among civilians both times. The marines did not fire back.)

In conditions where killing the snipers has proven difficult, the marines have tried to find ways to limit their effectiveness. Signs inside marine positions display an oft-spoken rule: "Make yourself hard to kill." Many marines, on operations, do an understated dance they call "cutting squares."

It is not really a square at all. They zig and zag as they walk, and when they stop, they shift weight from foot to foot, bobbing their heads. They change the rhythm often, so that when a sniper who might be scoping them thinks they are about to zig, they have zagged.

As they move, the marines often peer down their own scopes, looking at windows, rooftops, lines of brush. Then they might step backward, or forward, or duck, as if saying: try and shoot that.

But some marines, as operations drag on, begin to stop cutting squares. And sometimes, even those that are moving are still shot. And there are special dangers.

Lance Corporal Colin Smith, who was shot on Monday, was behind a machine gun in a vehicle turret, a position that placed him higher in the air than a walking marine. Turret gunners are protected by armor shields, but their heads are often exposed. He was struck in the skull. He survived but fell into a coma and was placed on life support.

Valdez-Castillo, who was shot on Tuesday, was a radio operator, a preferred sniper's target since radios and rifles first mixed on the battlefield decades ago. Ten marines, several soldiers from the nascent Iraqi Army and two journalists were walking exposed in a column when the shot was fired and he went down; his antenna likely made him the sniper's pick. Valdez-Castillo has been flown to a military hospital in Landstuhl, Germany. He is in good condition and has spoken to his unit.

In both cases, the sniper fired from the other side of a canal, among civilians and a group of buildings.

Some units have limited their foot patrols by day, finding them to be too dangerous. They still enter neighborhoods in armored vehicles and dismount, but often quickly step into buildings to interview Iraqis inside. They continue to patrol on foot at night, because the Iraqi snipers have not yet shown the sophistication to fire with precision in the dark, and the marines' night vision equipment and weapons sights give them the upper hand.

They also cover most of their vital organs with protective armor plates, which have saved several of the troops when the Iraqi snipers have fired. One marine, Gunnery Sergeant Shawn Dempsey of Weapons Company, was shot in the back as he helped a small girl across a street. The plate saved him. He remains on duty as a platoon commander.

Another, Lance Corporal Edward Knuth of Golf Company, was hit as his squad searched a watermelon market beside a main road. No one in his squad heard the shot, which he said was probably made from a vehicle parked on the highway. All they heard was the impact of the bullet on his plate.

"It was like a smacking sound," he said. The force of the impact, like being struck with a baseball bat, knocked him to his knees. A marine swiftly dragged him to cover. Then his squad rushed the line of cars. They found nothing. The sniper had escaped.

"They're good," Knuth said, showing a crumbling, coin-sized hole in his armor, where the bullet stopped. "They take their time. They're patient. They only take one shot most of the time and they are hard to find."

After Valdez-Castillo was shot and evacuated, a sweat-soaked, bloodied Leach led his team through the rest of his patrol. When the marines re-entered the wire, an angry debrief began. Move quickly through the open areas, the noncommissioned officers told the troops. Do not stand high on the berms. Camouflage the radios. Keep your eyes out and rifles ready.

Little was said about how to kill the sniper; the marines did not know where he was. They passed cigarettes and smoked them in the sun, and fumed.

"I'll carry the radio next time," said Lance Corporal Peter Sprague. "I don't have any kids."

Mike
11-08-2006, 05:08 AM
They zig and zag as they walk, and when they stop, they shift weight from foot to foot, bobbing their heads. They change the rhythm often, so that when a sniper who might be scoping them thinks they are about to zig, they have zagged.

As they move, the marines often peer down their own scopes, looking at windows, rooftops, lines of brush. Then they might step backward, or forward, or duck, as if saying: try and shoot that.

But some marines, as operations drag on, begin to stop cutting squares. And sometimes, even those that are moving are still shot.This is an enormous amount of stress to bear day after day, always trying to avoid being shot.

As part of their counterinsurgency operations, the marines working in Anbar are under orders to show restraint, a policy rooted in hopes of winning the trust of the civilian population.Restraint can be maintained for only so long. Eventually one of these guys, or perhaps a whole unit, will snap and commit an atrocity.

Felix the Cat
11-08-2006, 05:37 AM
Is the execution of francs-tireurs still legal?

How are armies nowadays expected to deal with this situation?

Mike
11-08-2006, 03:52 PM
Is the execution of francs-tireurs still legal?I'm not sure, but I believe the usual practice for US forces is to detain prisoners for interrogation. I don't recall reading about any executions per se, although doubtlessly spontaneous shootings of wounded insurgents occur here and there, including one caught on film, IIRC. Needless to say, if I were an Iraqi insurgent I would not want to fall into US hands alive. No picnic is in store for those guys.

How are armies nowadays expected to deal with this situation?That's a good question. When it's as far gone as it is in Iraq, there aren't a lot of open options. Officially, the goal is to "win the hearts and minds" of the civilians while trying to hobble together some sort of native force to take over the reins of security. The reality is that this sort of conflict is unwinnable for a foreign invader, short of interning (or liquidating) the local population. The soldiers like the ones described above will have to maintain order until the native Iraqi security force is ready, which may well be never.

Vasily Zaitsev
11-18-2006, 08:47 AM
Interesting that the article mentions rifles by name. I actually opened the thread to see if the insurgents were making their shots with Kalashnikovs, Dragunovs, or some other platform.

Though the article names Dragunovs specifically, I wonder how many of these "snipers" are fulfilling more of a designated marksman role and are using AKs. The AK is no sub-MOA weapon, but my experience at the range with my Bulgarian clone has lead me to believe that the rifle's reputation for poor accuracy has less to do with the platform and more to do with the "spray and pray" fire discipline of poorly trained armies.